New York, NY – June 02, 2025, 11:49 PM ET – Fox News’ The Five co-host Dana Perino is reportedly embroiled in a private rift with her stepdaughter Kelly McMahon, escalating tensions within the family after Perino refused to adhere to a long-standing family rule, sources close to the couple reveal. The 53-year-old political commentator, who recently purchased a $4.2 million luxury home in Summit, New Jersey, on May 25, 2025, has left the family atmosphere strained, highlighting the challenges of navigating blended family dynamics under the public eye.
The conflict centers on Perino’s decision not to include Kelly, 38, a marketing executive in London, on the deed of the newly acquired suburban estate—a move that already sparked hurt feelings, as reported by The Daily Mail on June 02. The deeper issue, however, lies in what the McMahon family considers an unspoken rule: major financial decisions, especially involving property, should involve all adult children to ensure transparency and unity. “Peter’s kids grew up expecting inclusion in big moves—it’s how the family stayed close,” an insider told Us Weekly. “Dana’s refusal to follow this tradition feels like a rejection to Kelly.”
Perino, married to Peter McMahon, 70, since 1998, has been a stepmother to his four children—Colin, Kelly, Lauren, and Mark—from his previous marriage. Despite her close bond with them, Perino reportedly views the rule as impractical, prioritizing her financial autonomy, especially after investing $3 million of her $6 million net worth (per ComingSoon.net) into Mira’s Hope Academy for orphans in Montana. “Dana’s always been meticulous with her money—she doesn’t see why adult stepkids need to co-own her assets,” the source added. Her recent motherhood to Mira, born via surrogacy in December 2024, may also be influencing her protective stance over her estate.
The rift has created a tense family atmosphere, with Kelly reportedly distancing herself, skipping a planned family gathering in Summit over Memorial Day weekend. Peter, caught in the middle, is said to be “heartbroken,” as he values unity among his children and Perino, whom he credits for his happiness, as shared in Perino’s 2022 podcast episode on A Dana Perino Podcast. The couple’s 27-year age gap and Perino’s role as a stepmother have occasionally stirred public curiosity, but this private conflict marks a rare glimpse into their challenges.
Social media reactions under #PerinoFamilyDrama reflect divided opinions. “Dana’s worked hard for her money—why should she share ownership?” one X user wrote, while another countered, “Family rules matter—Kelly deserves respect.” Fox News colleagues have remained supportive but silent, with Greg Gutfeld posting, “Dana’s got this—she’s a pro at handling tough spots.” Perino, known for mentoring young women and her composed demeanor on The Five, has not addressed the rift publicly, consistent with her private nature.
The tension underscores the complexities of blended families, especially when financial decisions intersect with emotional expectations. As Perino navigates her roles as a stepmother, new mother, and media star—while McMahon’s family grapples with this breach of tradition—the path to reconciliation remains uncertain, leaving fans hoping for a resolution that restores the family’s harmony.