Kayleigh McEnany’s Alleged Move to Italy: What’s Behind the Rumors and the Items Left Behind?

Kayleigh McEnany, the former White House press secretary and current Fox News co-host, has sparked a frenzy of speculation with unverified reports suggesting she has quietly relocated to Italy with her children. The rumors, amplified by social media chatter, claim that McEnany’s departure from the Fox News studio was so discreet that it caught fans off guard, with particular attention drawn to personal items she allegedly left behind. While no credible sources confirm this move, the story has taken on a life of its own, fueled by McEnany’s high-profile status and recent personal milestones. This article explores the origins of these claims, what McEnany supposedly left behind, and the broader context of her career and life in 2025.

The Rumors: A Silent Move to Italy?

The claim that Kayleigh McEnany has moved to Italy with her children emerged primarily from unverified social media posts and online speculation, with no confirmation from major news outlets or McEnany herself. Unlike her well-publicized pregnancy announcement in March 2025 and gender reveal in May 2025, which aired live on Fox News, there are no official statements or reports substantiating a relocation to Italy. A Yahoo report from April 2025 explicitly debunked rumors of McEnany leaving Fox News, stating she would continue her on-air presence despite her pregnancy, suggesting she remains professionally active in the U.S.

The Italy rumor appears to stem from a misinterpretation of McEnany’s personal life or perhaps her multilingual abilities, as noted in a Newsweek article mentioning her proficiency in English, Italian, and some French and Spanish. This linguistic background may have fueled speculation about a connection to Italy, though no evidence suggests she has relocated there. Social media posts on platforms like X have further amplified the narrative, with some users claiming McEnany’s “silent move” was motivated by a desire for privacy following the birth of her third child, a daughter, expected in June 2025. However, these claims remain inconclusive and lack corroboration from reputable sources.

What Did McEnany Leave Behind?

The most intriguing aspect of the rumor is the alleged discovery of personal items McEnany left behind at the Fox News studio. While specific details are scarce, social media buzz suggests these items include personal effects like a handbag, family photos, or even professional materials like notes or scripts. Fans have expressed shock at the idea that McEnany, known for her polished and meticulous public persona, would leave such items behind, interpreting it as a sign of a rushed or secretive departure. However, no verified reports confirm the existence or nature of these items, and the story appears to be largely speculative.

The notion of “items left behind” may be a sensationalized detail, possibly inspired by McEnany’s high-profile role and the emotional weight fans attach to her presence on Outnumbered. Her recent pregnancy and family-focused announcements, including sharing ultrasound images and discussing her children’s reactions to their new sibling, have endeared her to viewers, making any perceived abrupt exit feel personal. Without concrete evidence, the “left behind” narrative seems more symbolic than factual, reflecting fans’ surprise at the idea of McEnany stepping away from her visible role.

McEnany’s Current Status at Fox News

Kayleigh McEnany remains a prominent figure at Fox News, co-hosting Outnumbered and occasionally appearing on other programs like Fox News Tonight. Her recent professional activities include vocal commentary on political issues, such as criticizing CNN’s coverage of Trump’s tariff policies and defending Trump’s news cycles. In April 2024, she signed a multi-year contract extension with Fox News, signaling her commitment to the network. Reports from March and May 2025 confirm her active participation in Outnumbered, where she shared personal milestones like her pregnancy and gender reveal, further indicating she has not left the network.

Speculation about her departure may have been sparked by her temporary absence from Outnumbered during maternity preparations or earlier in 2023 when she briefly filled Tucker Carlson’s 8 p.m. slot after his exit from Fox News. These shifts, combined with her pregnancy, could have fueled rumors of a more permanent move, but all credible sources point to her continued presence at Fox News.

Personal Life and Possible Motivations

McEnany’s personal life has been in the spotlight recently, particularly with the announcement of her third child with husband Sean Gilmartin, a former MLB pitcher. The couple, already parents to Blake (five) and Nash (two), welcomed the news of their daughter with public joy, sharing moments like their ultrasound and Blake’s excitement on air. Her pregnancy, due in June 2025, aligns with the timeline of the rumored move, leading some to speculate that she might seek a quieter life abroad for her growing family. However, McEnany’s history of balancing motherhood with her high-profile career—evidenced by her return to Outnumbered after her second child’s birth in 2022—suggests she is unlikely to abandon her professional commitments entirely.

The Italy rumor might also reflect a broader trend of public figures seeking respite from the intense U.S. media landscape. McEnany’s tenure as Trump’s press secretary from April 2020 to January 2021 was marked by controversy, including accusations of spreading misinformation, which followed her to Fox News. A move to Italy could symbolize a fresh start, but without confirmation, this remains speculative.

Fan Reactions and Social Media Buzz

Fans’ reactions to the rumored move have been a mix of shock, curiosity, and skepticism. On X, some users expressed disbelief that McEnany would leave Fox News without a public announcement, given her transparency about personal milestones. Others speculated about the items left behind, with some suggesting they could be sentimental keepsakes or even props from her Outnumbered set. The lack of concrete details has led to polarized responses, with some fans defending McEnany’s loyalty to Fox News and others questioning whether the network’s evolving lineup—such as Lara Trump’s new show—prompted her alleged exit.

The rumor’s traction on X highlights the power of social media to amplify unverified narratives. Similar speculation surrounded McEnany in December 2024, when a YouTube video falsely claimed she was leaving Fox News due to a fallout with Trump, a claim debunked by credible sources. The Italy rumor appears to follow a similar pattern, driven by fan engagement rather than evidence.

Critical Analysis: Separating Fact from Fiction

The absence of credible reports confirming McEnany’s move to Italy suggests the story is likely a fabrication or exaggeration. Her recent on-air appearances, contract extension, and public focus on her pregnancy contradict the idea of a “silent move.” The detail about items left behind at the Fox News studio adds intrigue but lacks substantiation, resembling clickbait designed to capitalize on McEnany’s visibility. Her Italian language skills, while notable, do not inherently suggest a relocation, and her family’s roots in the U.S., combined with Gilmartin’s baseball background, make a sudden move abroad improbable without prior hints.

If McEnany were to take a break, it would more likely be tied to maternity leave, as seen with her second child’s birth in 2022. The emotional weight of the “items left behind” narrative may reflect fans’ attachment to her on-screen presence rather than any tangible evidence of departure.

What’s Next for Kayleigh McEnany?

As of June 2025, McEnany is expected to continue her role on Outnumbered until her third child’s birth, after which she may take maternity leave. Her history of returning to Fox News after previous pregnancies suggests she will remain a fixture on the network. The Italy rumor, while captivating, appears to be a distraction from her ongoing professional and personal commitments. Fans can likely expect more updates from McEnany on air, possibly addressing these rumors with her characteristic candor.

Conclusion

The story of Kayleigh McEnany’s alleged move to Italy with her children, coupled with the mystery of items left behind at the Fox News studio, is a compelling but unverified tale. Driven by social media speculation and lacking credible confirmation, the rumor reflects McEnany’s significant cultural presence and the public’s fascination with her life. As she prepares to welcome her third child and continues her role at Fox News, McEnany remains a polarizing yet enduring figure in conservative media. Until solid evidence emerges, the Italy narrative should be approached with skepticism, viewed as a product of fan-driven intrigue rather than fact.