Masterful Strategy” or “Cold-Bloodedness” on America’s Hottest Game Show? A case of “teammate assassination” has just rocked the set of *The Traitors US*.

Following the premiere of the first three episodes of “The Traitors” season 2, we asked you to split your votes in two polls: “Who is your favorite Traitor?” and “Who is your favorite Faithful?” Prior to Thursday night’s airing of episode 4, the results were in and they couldn’t be any clearer. Your favorite Traitor is “The Real Housewives of Atlanta” alum Phaedra Parks and your favorite Faithful is “MTV’s The Challenge” legend C.T. Tamburello.

Phaedra was selected as a Traitor in episode 1 by host Alan Cumming alongside “Big Brother” champion Dan Gheesling. In the first few rounds of play, Phaedra was content to sit back and let Dan take the lead in decisions, like the one to recruit “Survivor” winner Parvati Shallow as the third Traitor. By the end of episode 3, Phaedra stayed out of the fray once again by letting Dan and Parvati mastermind the poisoning of one of the faithful players with the special chalice. Though Dan and Parvati were doing most of the legwork early on, Phaedra’s under-the-radar approach and her close bond with the other “Housewives” was making her a strong candidate to last deep into the game with no target on her back. That could be why 42% of voters in our poll favored her as the top Traitor. Parvati pulled in 30% of the vote and Dan came in third with 28%.

Aside from the other “Housewives,” Phaedra was building a strong, if not unlikely, connection with C.T., a player she had briefly considered pushing to be their early recruit. C.T. came into the game alongside two other players and off-and-on rivals from “The Challenge,” Trishelle Cannatella and Johnny “Bananas” Devenanzio. At the start of episode 2, Bananas became the first murdered player and exited the game, but since then C.T. and Trishelle have found trust in one another. C.T. is also close to “Survivor” queen Sandra Diaz-Twine and “Big Brother” all star Janelle Pierzina among the faithful players, as well as Dan and Parvati, as part of a “gamers” clique. Pulling in 33% of the vote, C.T. is an overwhelming fan favorite among all of the Faithfuls. Janelle comfortably placed in second with 19% of the vote, followed by Carsten “Bergie” Bergersen from “Love Island USA” and Sandra each with just under 10%.

Scoring the worst in the poll were Kevin Kreider (“Bling Empire”), Tamra Judge (“The Real Housewives of Orange County”), Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu (“Love Island UK”), Trishelle, and UK Parliament’s John Bercow who all polled less than 2%. Those in the middle were Phaedra’s costar Shereé Whitfield with 6%, boxer Deontay Wilder with 5%, and Larsa Pippen (“The Real Housewives of Miami”), Peter Weber (“The Bachelor”), and Mercedes “MJ” Javid (“Shahs of Sunset”) with 4% each.